James McClean has responded to Roddy Collins' criticism by mocking the former Carlisle United manager's 2003 Football League Trophy final appearance. The ex-Republic of Ireland star called the competition 'not a good one' after Collins labeled him Derry City's worst signing. Next fixture: vs Eastleigh (at home, 2027-02-20) (13th in the table).
What happened?
McClean posted a TikTok video describing Collins' criticism as 'laughable'. He highlighted Collins' tenure at Derry City as unremarkable and mocked his biggest achievement-leading Carlisle to the 2003 Football League Trophy final, where they lost 2-0 to Bristol City. McClean dismissed the trophy as one 'you don’t really want on your CV'.
Why it matters for Carlisle
Collins managed Carlisle from 2001 to 2003, guiding them to the League Trophy final. McClean's remarks bring attention back to that era, contrasting Collins' modest success with his own illustrious career. The feud also reignites interest in Carlisle's past achievements under Collins.
What comes next?
With Carlisle set to face Eastleigh at home on 2027-02-20, currently 13th in the table, the focus shifts back to their current season. Meanwhile, McClean's spat with Collins continues, with both figures trading barbs over their respective careers and achievements.
