Carlisle United's decline in transparency comes down to a shortage of fans' forums and how boardroom interactions between the club and supporters' trust are reported. The 2026 index saw Carlisle placed highly overall, in seventh position nationally and the leading National League club, with their scores for dialogue and governance still high.
What happened?
The issue is not a suggestion that Carlisle have neglected supporter involvement – instead it comes down to the assurance created when supporters can see how their representatives are scrutinising decisions and engaging with the club at board level.
Why it matters for Carlisle
Rye said the involvement of the Trust, and United's engagement with wider supporters' groups, is a valuable set-up. In the case of the Trust, he said its role makes public reporting especially valuable.
What comes next?
Carlisle held one fans' forum last season – in April. The fan engagement index scores clubs higher when they hold at least two annually. With the club currently standing 17th in the National League, 5 points behind leaders Harrogate Town, and having scored 3 goals while conceding 4, the need for transparency and fan engagement is more important than ever. Their next fixture is against Eastleigh at home on February 20, 2027, and the team will be looking to improve their record of 0 wins, 1 draw, and 1 loss from their first 2 games.
